GadgetsNews wire, 2 h ago
Fitbit Air counted steps during long car drives, a reviewer reports
Reported by Android Police

Android Police reports that a reviewer is moving back from the Fitbit Air to a Samsung Galaxy Watch after finding a basic fault in the screenless tracker. The tracker kept adding steps while the wearer was driving. The article is a personal opinion piece based on one user's testing, not a lab test.
The reviewer bought the Fitbit Air to keep a favourite traditional watch on the wrist for weddings and family events, while still tracking steps, sleep, heart rate and other health measures. The screenless design and the lack of notifications were part of the appeal.
For the first few weeks the device seemed to work well, with no unusual fitness data. About a month into the test, the reviewer took a 250 km road trip and noticed the step count was wrong. Despite spending most of the time sitting behind the wheel, the tracker had logged around 5,000 steps. The same thing happened on other long drives. The reviewer believes that vibrations and movement from the car were counted as walking.
The reviewer says the step total matters because it is a large share of a daily activity goal. The fault also made the reviewer doubt the rest of the data, including sleep and heart rate. Apart from this problem, the experience was positive, but one fault was enough to change the choice of main tracker.
After switching back to a Galaxy Watch, the reviewer reports several long drives without a similar problem. The reviewer says the goal is not perfect accuracy for every step. The goal is numbers that reflect real activity rather than road vibration. The Galaxy Watch also offers notifications, Samsung Wallet, the Gemini assistant and watch face complications, which the reviewer values. The trade-off is that the favourite watch cannot be worn while tracking fitness at the same time.
The reviewer does not call the Galaxy Watch perfect. The Samsung Health app is described as dated in layout and navigation compared with Google Health, and the reviewer dislikes the promotional banners and ads inside it. Samsung is praised for its hardware and core tracking, but the reviewer says the software needs more polish.
The reviewer says the Fitbit Air nearly won them over, citing its minimalist look, comfortable design and the promise of health insights without another screen. Still, the driving problem is a basic fault. The reviewer is not giving up on the device permanently, but will stay with the Galaxy Watch until Google fixes the issue. The reviewer has already changed settings on the Galaxy Watch to get more from it.
The article does not say whether Google has acknowledged the problem or plans a fix. It also does not say whether other Fitbit Air owners see the same results, or how the tracker detects movement.
Enjoying this? Get the Gadgets brief
Every Monday: the gadgets worth your money.
✓ Free · seven editions · one click to leave
Original reporting by the sources above. Summary by smart-home.space.