Apple TV 4K 4th generation at $300: who the upgrade suits and who can skip it
Eric Welander tests Apple's new streaming box against older models, HomePods and Sonos speakers, and finds it pays off mainly for a specific kind of home theatre.
We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. It never changes what we recommend.
Apple TV 4K 4th generation at $300: who the upgrade suits and who can skip it. Plays from YouTube (privacy-enhanced mode).This is our summary of Eric Welander’s video, published with their permission. The full video and all credit for it are on their channel.
What the video covers
Introduction to the new Apple TV 4K 4th Generation, its new features, and the central question of whether it is worth the $300 price tag.
Unboxing the Apple TV 4K 4th Generation, examining its physical design, remote, and setup process.
Analyzing the value proposition of the new Apple TV 4K compared to previous models and other smart home devices.
Demonstrating how to set up the Apple TV 4K with HomePods and HomePod minis for a surround sound home theater experience.
Comparing different speaker options, such as four HomePod minis versus a Sonos soundbar and subwoofer setup.
Final thoughts on whether to purchase the new Apple TV 4K or stick with older hardware.
Apple has released a new Apple TV 4K, the 4th generation, priced at $300. In his review, Eric Welander looks at what has changed from the previous model, including the A19 chip, Wi-Fi 7 support, built-in microphones and a remote that can play a sound to help you find it. The central question he asks is whether the price is justified for most people.
His answer is mostly no, with exceptions. He says the device is aimed at people building a surround sound setup around several Apple speakers, and at owners of much older Apple TV models. For recent owners, and for anyone who mainly wants smart home controls, he sees little reason to pay for it.
What has changed in the new box
Outwardly the unit looks the same as its predecessor, with the same power cable and port layout. Inside, Welander points to the new A19 chip and Wi-Fi 7 support. A small LED sits on the front, and microphones around the edge let you speak to Siri directly, for example to make the remote play its sound or to ask about something in a film.
He also notes that the box works as a Home hub for Apple Home and is the most capable of Apple's hubs, because it can be connected over Ethernet.
But at $300, is it really worth the upgrade for a lot of people?
Who can skip the upgrade
Welander is clear that owners of the 2021 and 2022 Apple TV models should not rush to buy this one. In his view, smart home control is a pleasant extra of the Apple TV rather than a reason to buy it, especially now that devices such as the HomePod mini 2 and the Apple HomeView cover much of that role.
He also argues that the extra microphones add little value if the box sits inside a rack or cabinet, and that many people already use a separate remote for the rest of their system.
One of the strengths I think of Apple's kind of wireless setup, too, compared to other systems, is that when you have four different speakers, they can be placed in a lot of different places around your room.
Who gains the most
Owners of older models, particularly ones that cannot handle 4K, are the group that should notice the biggest difference. Welander expects a clear gain in speed, along with support for newer video and colour formats. He also mentions FaceTime through Continuity Camera as an extra.
The A19 chip can decode AV1, a video format that he describes as more efficient for high-quality streaming. He points out, however, that the box still lacks digital audio pass-through for sending sound on to a receiver.
Building a surround setup from HomePods
Welander's favourite feature is the way the Apple TV sets up a surround group with four HomePod 2 or HomePod mini 2 speakers. The calibration runs automatically using the built-in microphones, so no specialist knowledge is needed, and the process shows colour-coded visuals on screen. The group appears in Apple Home as a single audio target called Home Theater.
On the Apple TV you can adjust the rear speaker level, choose whether spatial audio applies to music or only to films, and switch to a whole-room mode for background music. The Sound Glow feature matches the colours of the speakers' top lights to album art, which he leaves on as a sign that the speakers are working. The EQ options are limited.
Apple against Sonos
Welander compares the Apple setup with his own Sonos system, which includes an Arc Ultra soundbar, a Sub Gen 4 and two Era 100 rear speakers. In his basement, the Sonos soundbar sits low to fit a large screen, so it sounds muffled, while the two HomePod 2s on either side of the screen project better. Four HomePods gave him more clarity in music and dialogue, though the Sonos subwoofer delivers much more bass.
He also notes that using the HomePods frees an HDMI port on his projector that the soundbar had occupied, and that the Wi-Fi connection was reliable in his tests.
Our verdict
Welander's conclusion is that the new Apple TV 4K is now a niche product. It makes sense for people who want four speakers placed around the room, when a soundbar and subwoofer are not practical. For a more casual setup, he recommends two rear HomePod mini 2 speakers, since they can later move elsewhere in the home if the owner upgrades.
Enjoying this? Get the Gadgets brief
Every Monday: the gadgets worth your money.
✓ Free · seven editions · one click to leave


