Apple TV 4K (4th generation): what the $299 model adds for smart homes

Shane Whatley spent two weeks with the new Apple TV 4K. He tested its A19 chip, far-field microphones, four-HomePod surround sound and Matter support, and asks whether the upgrade is worth $299.

We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. It never changes what we recommend.

New Apple TV 4K After 2 Weeks: Don’t Upgrade Unless...Apple TV 4K (4th generation): what the $299 model adds for smart homes. Plays from YouTube (privacy-enhanced mode).

This is our summary of Shane Whatley’s video, published with their permission. The full video and all credit for it are on their channel.

What the video covers

0:00
Introduction

Introduction to the new Apple TV 4K, its features, and what you need to know about the 4th generation.

1:44
What's New in Apple TV 4K 4th Generation

Overview of the new hardware updates, including the A19 chip, AV1 video decoding, and built-in far-field microphones.

5:10
Home Theater Surround Sound Setup

Detailed look at setting up four HomePods or HomePod minis for wireless surround sound with Apple TV 4K.

15:13
Siri AI and Smart Home Integration

Testing Siri AI features, hands-free voice control, and smart home hub capabilities with Matter support.

20:18
The New Siri Remote

Review of the new Siri remote with Find My precision finding and a built-in speaker.

22:25
Linkind Smart Lighting Accessories

Demonstration of Linkind smart light stick and smart filament bulb integration with Apple Home.

25:15
Smart Home Security & Camera Integration

How Apple TV 4K handles security cameras, doorbells, and notifications.

26:46
Streaming Apps, AirPlay, and AirPods

Overview of streaming services, Apple Fitness+, FaceTime, SharePlay, and private listening with AirPods.

29:09
Is the Apple TV 4K Worth $299?

Final verdict on whether the new Apple TV 4K is worth the upgrade and price tag.

Shane Whatley, a long-time Apple TV user with several units around his house, has spent two weeks testing the new fourth-generation Apple TV 4K. He says Apple sent him the unit before release, and that the video is not sponsored by Apple. It is sponsored by the lighting maker Linkind, which is covered in a separate part of the video.

His verdict is that the price of $299 is hard to justify on speed alone. He sees the most value for existing Apple owners who want hands-free Siri or four-speaker surround sound, and for people who run an Apple Home setup and want a capable hub.

What is new in the fourth-generation box

The headline hardware change is Apple's A19 chip. Whatley reports up to 50% faster CPU performance and twice the GPU performance compared with the previous model. The box also adds dedicated AV1 video decoding. He explains that AV1 is a more efficient format, used by services such as YouTube and Netflix, that can deliver good picture quality with less bandwidth.

Three far-field microphones are built into the front and sides of the unit. Together with the chip, these changes are the basis of the new model. Whatley points out that some of the other features he covers also reach older Apple TVs, so buyers should check which items need the new hardware.

With the new fourth-generation Apple TV 4K, we get Apple's A19 chip with up to 50% faster CPU performance and twice the GPU performance compared to the previous model.

Shane Whatley, at 2:04 in the video

Surround sound with four HomePods

The most anticipated feature is wireless surround sound using up to four HomePods or HomePod minis. Only the second-generation full-size HomePod and the second-generation HomePod mini are supported, and the original minis are excluded. The Apple TV then calibrates timing and levels for the room. Three layouts are possible, from two full-size and two mini speakers to four full-size units.

Whatley only owns three full-size HomePods, so he tested the layout with two full-size speakers at the front and two new minis at the back. He found the rear minis made a clear difference over his existing stereo pair, and he praised the easy setup. He estimates four full-size HomePods would cost almost $1,400, and his mixed setup just under $1,000 new. He sees the rear minis as a sensible add-on, for about $300, for people who want surround without a receiver, speaker wires or a subwoofer. The Apple TV does not offer native pass-through for Dolby TrueHD or DTS-X, which he flags for audiophiles.

Apple's most capable yet most expensive Apple TV to date. I think it really depends on a couple of things.

Shane Whatley, at 29:11 in the video

Siri AI, microphones and the new remote

With the microphones, Whatley could call Siri from across a room, even with the Apple TV hidden behind a cabinet. He notes that if HomePods are permanently paired, they keep handling voice commands, so the new microphones matter less. Siri AI can use personal context from messages, calendars and reminders, but it needs an Apple Intelligence-capable iPhone. On the TV, answers appear on screen rather than spoken aloud.

The Siri remote looks the same as before. It now has a speaker that plays a sound, and precision finding in the Find My app when paired with a compatible iPhone. Older remotes gained Find My support but lack precision finding and the speaker. The new remote is sold separately for $59.

A smart home hub with Matter and Thread

The new unit works as an Apple Home hub, supports Thread and Matter, and can run automations and remote control. Whatley says that compatible devices from many brands can join Apple Home through it. He tested two Linkind products: a light stick with 160 LEDs split into 50 colour zones and more than 120 preset scenes, and a Matter-compatible filament bulb that can change colour, shift between warm and cool white and dim. Both were controlled with Siri and included in his scenes, provided a hub such as the Apple TV is present.

Camera and doorbell alerts appear on the TV without interrupting playback, and Apple Home's newer AI features add activity descriptions and summaries when the right devices and iCloud plan are in place. Whatley stresses that these camera features are not exclusive to the new model.

Streaming, AirPlay and everyday use

Beyond the new hardware, the Apple TV offers the usual apps, Apple Music, Apple Arcade, Fitness+ and FaceTime with the iPhone as camera. AirPlay, using the iPhone as a remote, SharePlay and private listening through AirPods all remain available. Whatley says he uses private listening most, especially late at night, and that several AirPods can be paired for a group.

He says the previous generation already handles everyday streaming well. The faster chip is more likely to show up in gaming and heavier apps.

Is the $299 price justified?

Whatley calls the new model Apple's most capable and most expensive Apple TV. For a first purchase he says it is the strongest option, with a good interface, a capable hub and good integration across Apple devices. For people who only stream video, he thinks the price is hard to defend.

He advises owners of the previous 4K model not to rush, unless they want hands-free Siri or four-speaker surround. Owners of the first-generation boxes, which he notes are more than nine years old, are the group he plans to upgrade. He also says the Wi-Fi 7 and faster processor may not show a clear benefit for smart home performance, and that remains to be seen.

RelatedApple HomeView review: a smart display that goes well beyond home controlsRelatedHow to start a smart home: a beginner's guide to devices and systems

Enjoying this? Get the Smart Home brief

Every Tuesday: what changed in Matter, hubs and security.

✓ Free · seven editions · one click to leave

Topics
Add us as a preferred source on GoogleSee our stories first in Google’s Top Stories.
Get alerts on big newsOnly the big news, at most once a day. No email, no account.